Grey Friday Sale — up to 17% off. Ends Dec 15.
← Back to Field Notes

Heat-Set Inserts That Pull Out Aren’t Too Cold — The Hole Has Nowhere for the Plastic to Go

November 21, 2026 · 5 min read

A heat-set insert goes in, the screw goes in, and on the third tightening the insert spins in place or comes out with the screw. Or it creeps up a millimetre after you lift the iron, or the boss bulges around it. The usual fix is to turn the iron up, and the next insert sinks faster, tilts, and holds no better. Temperature is rarely the problem. An insert works by displacing plastic into its knurls, and how well it holds is decided by where that displaced plastic can go: the hole depth, the hole size you actually printed, and the walls around it.

What you seeWhat it means
Insert creeps back up after you lift the ironBlind hole printed to the insert length: the displaced melt has no room below and is pushing it back out
Insert spins or pulls out with the screwThe melt flowed away from the knurls, into hollow infill or a gap, so nothing locked them: wall too thin, not iron too cold
Insert sinks crookedOne side of the hole is walls, the other is infill, so it melts unevenly; or the tip is pushing off-axis
Face of the boss bulges or cracksThe hole printed undersized: there is up to 30% more plastic to move than the datasheet assumes
Screw binds at the bottom of the insertMelt was squeezed ahead of the insert into its threads: hole too small or too shallow

An Insert Is a Volume Problem

Take the common M3 x 5.7 mm insert. CNC Kitchen’s datasheet gives it a 4.6 mm outer diameter, a 4.0 mm hole, a minimum wall of 1.6 mm, and a blind hole about 1 mm deeper than the insert. The gap between 4.6 and 4.0 mm is a ring of plastic 4.05 mm² in area, and over 5.7 mm of length that is about 23 mm³ of plastic the insert has to push aside. Some of it flows into the knurls, which is what you want: that is the grip. The rest has to go somewhere else.

In a solid moulded boss, it compresses into the surrounding material. In a print, the surrounding material is two or three perimeters and then air. If the walls are thin, the melt pushes through them into the infill and the knurls are left half-empty. If the hole stops at the insert length, the melt piles up underneath, and when you lift the iron that pool pushes the insert back up as it settles. The extra 1 mm of depth is a reserve of about 12.6 mm³ for exactly that.

Then there is the hole you actually printed. Small holes come out undersized, often by 0.1–0.2 mm. A 4.0 mm CAD hole that prints at 3.8 mm takes the displaced volume from about 23 mm³ to about 30 mm³. That is the bulge on the face of the boss, and the burr that binds the screw.

M3 x 5.7 INSERT IN A 4.0 mm HOLE (SECTION, NOT TO SCALE) hole = insert length, 2 walls (0.9 mm) melt pools below and leaks into infill CREEPS OUT, SPINS +1 mm depth, 4 walls (~1.8 mm) melt fills the knurls and the reserve SEATED FLUSH, HOLDS
Same insert, same iron. On the left the melt has nowhere to go but back up and out into the infill; on the right it fills the knurls and the depth reserve.

In This Order

  1. 1
    Measure the printed hole, not the CAD holePrint a test boss and check the hole with a drill shank or pin gauge. If a 4.0 mm hole prints at 3.8 mm, compensate in CAD for that hole only, rather than with a global XY offset that moves every other dimension.
  2. 2
    Give the hole a depth reserveFor a blind hole, model it at least 1 mm deeper than the insert: 6.7 mm for the M3 x 5.7. A through hole needs no reserve, because the melt can leave out the bottom.
  3. 3
    Make the wall out of perimetersThe 1.6 mm minimum wall should be solid perimeters, not perimeters plus infill. At a 0.45 mm line width that is four walls, about 1.8 mm, so the melt flows into plastic rather than air. Raise the wall count, or add a modifier around the boss.
  4. 4
    Set the iron 10–20 °C above print temperature, no hotterAbout 225 °C for PLA and 245 °C for PETG. Hotter does not grip better; it sinks the insert faster than the plastic can flow into the knurls, and it drags melt down ahead of it.
  5. 5
    Press straight, finish coldMelt it in about 90% of the way, then press it flush with a flat tool and hold for a few seconds while it sets. That last cold press is what stops the creep-out.

A Worked Example

A PETG enclosure lid with four M3 bosses, two walls at 0.45 mm and 15% infill, blind holes modelled at 4.0 x 5.7 mm. The holes print at 3.8 mm. Two inserts creep up proud of the surface; one spins out on first assembly. The iron goes from 245 to 270 °C and the next inserts tilt. Back to 245 °C, holes modelled at 4.2 x 6.7 mm so they print at 4.0 x 6.7 mm, four walls around each boss, and the last 10% pressed flush with a flat tool. All four inserts sit flush, and none spin at assembly torque. Same inserts, same iron, same material. The only changes were the hole and the plastic around it.


More Infill Is Not More Wall

The reflex after a spun insert is to raise infill to 50% or 100%. It helps a little, but slowly and expensively: infill lines are still separated by gaps, and they meet the perimeters at a weak seam. Four perimeters around the boss give a solid ring for the knurls to bite into, for a fraction of the material. It is the same reason wall count, not infill percentage, sets the strength of most printed parts, and why a printed hole is never quite the size you drew. Both are covered in the posts linked below.

Material Note: PCTG

PCTG is a confident choice for parts with threaded inserts. Its modified CHDM structure gives it a clear step up in toughness from PETG, so a boss that takes an insert flexes instead of cracking at the face, and its moisture uptake is around 0.15%, lower than PLA, so the walls around the hole print dense and dimensionally steady. Set the iron 10–20 °C above your PCTG print temperature and use the same hole rules: depth reserve, solid perimeters, a cold final press.

If a part needs inserts that hold to a specific torque, or a hole that has to land on a tolerance, ask before you order. What FDM can and cannot hold is set out in our realistic capabilities.

Inserts That Seat Flush and Stay Put

DuffAM sizes insert holes to the printed result, builds the boss from solid walls and sets each insert by hand, so threads hold at assembly torque.

Order Direct at DuffAM →